Sector News

Managing diversity in the modern workforce shouldn’t be a zero-sum game

April 5, 2018
Diversity & Inclusion

For a couple years now, a few of my clients have tasked me with the challenge of helping them identify minority candidates for employment in their organization.

At first, I was very excited. Why? Because for many years, they have told me that they could not find qualified candidates for their open positions.

My response was simple: “You are not looking hard enough. There are many qualified minority candidates out there in your profession.”

Finally, they told me, “OK, you have the green light, you go help us find them.”

In terms of increasing demographic diversity of staff at an educational institution, I found that the answer was not as easy as I originally thought.

Three major roadblocks get on the way of remediation of workplace inequality in diversity representation.

The first challenge is the assumption within an organization that diversity policies make companies fairer to minorities and women. Nothing could be farther from the truth.

In a recent study published in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, young white men went through a hiring process for an entry-level job at a fictional technology firm. Half of these “applicants” interviewed in a firm where recruitment materials mentioned the firm’s nondiscriminatory diversity values (i.e. “minorities encouraged to apply”).

The materials for the second firm did not mention diversity. All of the applicants then underwent a standardized job interview.

The result was fascinating. Everything else remaining the same, participants applying to the pro-diversity company made a poorer impression during the interview, and expressed more concerns about being discriminated against than those applying to the neutral company.

These findings suggest that whites may be more sensitive to identity threats than we would commonly assume. The mere mention of diversity in a company’s policies may make white employees believe that minorities and women are being treated fairly, but also that they themselves are being treated unfairly.

The second set of challenges derive directly from the first one. When the strategic plan and other policies in an organization suggest a tendency of the company to hire with diversity representation in mind, the majority white staff resist diversity as they feel the threat of losing their privileged positions.

The third hindrance of increasing minority representation in an organization is created by the minority themselves. Participants from ethnic minorities viewed a pro-diversity company as no more inclusive.

In my attempt to attract minority candidates to predominantly majority white organizations, I have often been asked by minority candidates why I wanted them to be the first or the only minority there.

The most common reason for minorities not to even be willing to consider applying is, “If they have not yet recruited minorities, it’s because they don’t want minorities; why should I be the first?”

Minorities are thus also reluctant to embrace an environment where they may feel experience discrimination, whether it’s an accurate view or not.

Hunan psychologists find these three challenges troubling in the strugles to achieve workplace diversity and foster inclusion in our organizations.

By Emmanuel Ngomsi

Source: Kansas City Business Journal

comments closed

Related News

December 3, 2022

Research: men speak more abstractly than women

Diversity & Inclusion

When someone gives a speech, leads a meeting, or sends us an email, we don’t generally think much about how abstract or concrete their language is. But the authors’ research suggests that this subtle difference in communication style can substantially impact how people are perceived, as more-abstract speech tends to be associated with power and leadership.

November 27, 2022

Remote work boosts employees with disabilities, research shows

Diversity & Inclusion

The share of prime working-aged disabled individuals with a job is now the highest since at least the Great Recession, marking important progress; the evidence in this analysis suggests that a strong labor market is one important factor and the growth of remote work is another.

November 19, 2022

The global population is aging. Is your business prepared?

Diversity & Inclusion

While political, economic, and technological shifts can be difficult to predict, demographics data doesn’t lie. Within the next 10 years, more than 60 countries will have a median age over 35, and in 25 of those countries, half the population will be over 45.