Sector News

Have we created a trap for passionate leaders?

October 25, 2018
Borderless Leadership

One of the things that is so frequently demanded of leaders is passion. We want our leaders to have a passion about their vision, for success, to deliver results and to care about the purpose of their organisation and its people. It is the passionate leader whose heart is really in it, not just their head, who cares deeply about working for the higher purpose of their organisation and, in doing so, brings others along with them.

The popularity of servant leadership is testament to how motivating it can be to work towards a higher purpose, about which everyone in the organization cares deeply. This purpose is in the DNA of the organization. It is the culture and the very fabric of it, and many leaders are able to convey their passion for this higher purpose and unite people in a collective understanding of its direction, mission and values.

Modern leadership also sees an increasing focus on ethics, and how important it is to be ethical in our decision-making, to run a responsible organisation and to speak out when we see unethical behaviour. The Institute of Leadership & Management recognizes that challenging is a key component of great leadership. It is the ability to ask a question about the value or truth of a decision and when decisions are not immediately reconsidered, having the determination to keep on with that challenge. But what about when there is only one moment, one opportunity to make you point, or the moment is lost.

Rafael Nadal of Spain argues a call during play against Roger Federer of Switzerland in the men’s final during the NASDAQ-100 Open at the Crandon Park Tennis Center on April 3, 2005 in Key Biscayne, Florida. (Photo by Clive Brunskill/Getty Images)

Serena Williams was in that very position in this year’s final of the U.S. Open and although we all claim to admire passion, heart-felt commitment and the strength to challenge when we see wrong doing, when Williams displayed these qualities in her objection to Carlos Ramos’ accusation that she was cheating, she was harshly criticized. Her response, seen by some as hysterical, could equally be interpreted as passionate, heartfelt and demonstrating her determination to challenge wrongs.

Despite our yearning for passionate leaders we also ask that they are cool, calm and measured – or perhaps is it that we particularly require our female leaders to be so? A reaction characterized as hysterical in Williams, may have been considered outspoken or courageous from Djokovic or Nadal. As with the practice of leadership everywhere, context is key and a grand slam tennis final is a very particular environment, so while we may not approve of Williams’ actions, the incident highlights the downside of passion, and the negative response women managers may invoke when they are ‘too passionate.’

However, remaining composed and unruffled when confronted with ethical wrongs makes it very difficult to muster the energy required to speak out and challenge when it is necessary. So here we have a modern leadership dilemma; almost a trap we have created for our leaders. We find ourselves in the impossible position of being required to speak out against wrong, to be passionate about our purpose but also to be somehow measured and calm in how we challenge what we consider to be wrong decisions.

By Kate Cooper

Source: Forbes

comments closed

Related News

May 4, 2024

How to spot a bad leader from the beginning — and what to do next

Borderless Leadership

We’ve all worked for bosses who could have been better — in some cases much better — but inexplicably they remain in charge. Barbara Kellerman has been studying that phenomenon for much of her career. Her latest book, “Leadership from Bad to Worse: What Happens When Bad Festers,” is both a cautionary tale and a call to action.

April 26, 2024

Stay silent? Speak up? How CEOs can navigate a polarized world

Borderless Leadership

CEOs are spending more time on making the business case for their environmental and social commitments, and they’re building more rigorous mechanisms for addressing thorny issues and mitigating PR risks. To avoid communications missteps, CEOs should ensure they have the organizational capabilities and tools in place to monitor and analyze emerging issues and to gauge the sentiment of key stakeholders.

April 20, 2024

Employers worry training won’t keep pace with tech advancement

Borderless Leadership

The vast majority of business leaders responding to a recent survey said they’re concerned they can’t train employees quickly enough to keep up with AI and tech developments in the next three years. A similar amount said AI and other tech disruptions will require companies to rethink skills, resources and new ways of doing work.

How can we help you?

We're easy to reach