Zero Waste Europe (ZWE), the European Environmental Citizen’s Organisation for Standardisation (ECOS), and nine other organizations are urging the European Commission (EC) to avoid a flexible “mass balance approach” method in determining recycled content in plastic products.
The signatories delivered a joint letter yesterday evening to the EC advising it to establish a “transparent, ambitious, and circular ‘chain of custody’” method instead.
Signed by several civil society organizations and recycling industry members, the letter is a “direct objection” to the recent calls of key industry players, including chemical recycling actors, for a “mass balance approach,” ZWE explains.
“This method could allow for the liberal allocation of recycled feedstock to the final product of their choosing, regardless of its true content.”
“In practice, a plastic product could be sold as ‘fully recycled’ while containing only very small fractions of actual recycled content under the ‘mass balance approach.’”
According to the Ellen MacArthur Foundation’s Mass Balance White Paper, “mass balance accounting” is designed to trace the flow of materials through a complex value chain. The mass balance approach provides a set of rules for allocating recycled content to different products to claim and market the content as “recycled-based.”
Criteria to avoid greenwashing
The joint letter recommends the EC base its method on ten specific criteria to avoid greenwashing practices and regulate how recycled content is determined, guaranteeing a circular chain of custody:
These criteria are further explained in the “Determining recycled content with the ‘mass balance approach’ – 10 recommendations for development of methods and standards” joint policy briefing, published in February by ZWE, ECOS, and the Rethink Plastic alliance.
Ensuring recycling transparency
The EU is targeting a minimum packaging recycling rate by weight of 65 percent by the end of 2025 and 70 percent by 2030. Moreover, the EU Plastics Strategy requires all packaging to be recyclable in an economically viable way by 2030.
Meanwhile, the EU’s SUPD requires at least 25 percent recycled plastic in PET bottles by 2025 and 30 percent in all beverage bottles from 2030. Its recently introduced plastics tax also imposes a €0.80/kg (US$0.97/kg) levy on non-recycled plastic packaging waste.
“The EU targets for recycled content could be a huge driver for recycling – that is, unless we introduce loose methods for reporting the share of recycled content in plastics which remove such incentives, mislead consumers and risk damaging the credibility of the recycling industry,” comments Shanar Tabrizi, chemical recycling and plastic to fuel officer at ZWE.
“What we call for is plastic transparency, fair and square.”
Toward this end, the EC awarded blockchain transparency platform Circularise a €1.5 million (US$1.2 million) grant in 2020. Blockchain technology can be particularly effective in monitoring Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) schemes.
“The Single-Use Plastic Directive (SUPD) was a true breakthrough for environmental policy. But with the ‘mass balance approach,’ we open the door to the creative accounting of recycled plastic content,” adds Mathilde Crépy, senior programme manager at ECOS.
“If we allow manufacturers to play with the numbers in their recycled content claims, our planet will suffer the consequence. We can’t afford it being watered down by a flexible chain of custody allowing for creative accounting of recycled content.”
The European Parliament recently voted in favor of the EC’s Circular Economy Action Plan, demonstrating support for permanent materials, recyclable without loss of quality.
by Joshua Poole
Two Tetra Pak production sites in Europe are now certified to produce packaging with recycled polyethylene (rPE) polymers, according to the Roundtable on Sustainable Biomaterials (RSB) Chain of Custody mass balance attribution method.
Cargill has appointed Brian Sikes as its chief operating officer (COO), a role in which he will also serve as a management director on the company’s board.
Heineken has reached an agreement with The Coca-Cola Company and the Coca-Cola System in Brazil to redesign their long-standing distribution partnership in the country.