Swiss construction and automotive chemicals maker Sika AG has repeated its opposition to its takeover by French building materials giant Saint-Gobain SA, a year after the bitter $2.76 billion takeover battle began.
Sika Chairman Paul Hälg has written an open letter to Saint-Gobain shareholders saying the planned takeover, which was first announced on Dec. 8 last year, would destroy value at both companies.
“The intended transaction lacks industrial logic and will destroy value for all shareholders,” Mr. Hälg wrote in the letter.
A spokesman for Saint-Gobain declined to comment on the letter.
The takeover has proved controversial because Paris-based Saint-Gobain has proposed only to buy the 16% stake held by Sika’s founding Burkard family for 2.75 billion Swiss francs ($2.75 billion). Buying the family’s investment vehicle gives control of Sika as it has 52% of the voting rights in the Swiss company.
Baar-based Sika has responded by limiting the family’s voting rights to 5%, a move which is now being disputed in Swiss courts, with a decision expected in the middle of next year.
“Twelve months after the announcement of the intended transaction there is still no end of the conflict in sight,” said Mr. Hälg.
Mr. Hälg said cost savings expected by Saint-Gobain were unrealistic, especially as the two companies are in direct competition in the mortar business. The cash return to Saint-Gobain shareholders would also be minimal, he said.
Sika, which makes chemicals used to reinforce concrete and soundproof of cars, would also be damaged by a takeover, while many Sika managers have raised concerns about a transaction, he added.
“With the support of the entire management team, employee representatives and virtually all of the public shareholders, the non-conflicted board members will continue to act in the best interest of Sika and, therefore, oppose the intended transaction,” wrote Mr. Hälg.
By John Revill
Source: Wall Street Journal
The total contract value is approximately €430 million. The project scope of work entails complete engineering services, equipment and material supply, installation and construction activities and, as an optional part of the scope, commissioning and start up.
Once it has implemented this project, Lenzing will have biological wastewater treatment plants that meet the best available techniques (BAT) quality standard at all its production sites.
The debate over the position of hydrogen in the new energy revolution has come to the fore again thanks to Japan’s hosting of the Olympic Games. But rather than showcasing how green this miracle new fuel is, it has highlighted its many problems.